· r e j i q u a r · w o r k s ·
the various and sundry creations of sylvus tarn

19nov2026

cropThis gorgeous piece by my bestie has been languishing for years, and in celebration of her new hobby (writing fantasy/romance/romantasy) I think it's entirely appropriate to use it for a review of two retellings of my all-time favourite faerytale, Beauty and the Beast.

Faery tales have this association with being folk tales of no particular author, but Beauty and the Beast does, in fact, have an author, Gabrielle-Suzanne Barbot de Villeneuve which, yes, I have read (in translation, obviously) and which, frankly, is kind of boring. There are a lot of variants of this story, but the one I imprinted upon as a child goes like this:

A rich merchant has three beautiful daughters, of whom the two elder are cruel, but the youngest, Beauty, is most beautiful, as well as kind. He loses everything, (including his elder two daughters’ respect and affection) but learns that one ship has made it back to port; to celebrate, he asks his daughters what gifts they would like, and the elder two ask for fancy dresses and jewels; Beauty, only a rose.

Returning home, he's lost in a dreadful storm, but welcomed to a mysterious castle, where he's treated kindly; but dismayed that he can't bring his daughters their promised gifts, upon seeing a garden of roses, plucks one for Beauty; at this point the enraged Beast appears, threatening to kill him for theft. Terrified, the merchant explains that he is very sorry, and just wanted to please his daughter, and begs the Beast to spare his life, as his children's wife is dead and they have no-one else. The Beast relents, upon the condition that he return with one of this daughters instead at some specified time in the future to take his place.

IIRC, the merchant merely plans to say goodbye and return to his doom, but upon hearing of his fate, Beauty (encouraged by her selfish older sisters) volunteers to go. Instead of killing her, the Beast gives her ‘Beauty's Room’, an exquisite chamber, far grander than anything she ever experienced at the height of her father's wealth. The rest of the magical palace is wondrous and sumptuous, full of every kind of entertainment; every night, after an extravagant dinner served by invisible servants, the Beast asks Beauty to marry him, but she can (& does) always reply no. As time passes, Beauty, exploring the fabulous castle, finds a bracelet featuring a miniature of a beautiful young man caught in a chandelier; she dreams of him, falling in love, but when she wakes can only recall that he seems sad about something.

Eventually, the Beast allows homesick Beauty to return home with a magic ring that will return her to the palace along with a warning that she must arrive by the deadline (a week or a month, again, it's been over half a century...;) or he'll die of grief. So off she goes, and her sisters are immediately jealous of her splendid raiment, so they conspire to keep her past the deadline. But then Beauty has a dream of the Beast dying, so she returns to the castle at the last moment, finds the Beast almost expired, and, realizing she loves him after all despite his hideous appearance, declares she will marry him; and so the curse is removed and he's revealed to be the prince (literally) of her dreams and they live happily ever after. Also, I think her evil (step?) sisters get turned to statues for their wicked efforts to betray Beauty.

Though I can still see the painting of Beauty reaching up to the chandelier for the locket, some 50 plus years later I doubt I'll ever find that exact retelling, but this superb Walter Crane version is very close, and honestly, his illustrations are even better. (Here's another classic version.) When I encountered Robin McKinley's Beauty in college, it forever cemented the gold standard of what any faery tale retelling in general and this one in particular should be. McKinley retains almost all the original elements, sharpening or substituting them in marvelous ways (the original winged horses become her beloved charger, Greatheart, and the evil sisters, loving, a subversion I really appreciated; also, the Beast himself explains that it is not he who will slaughter her father if the bargain is not fulfilled, but that the curse would cause Beauty to grow to hate her beloved father from guilt; etc.) The magical entertainments transmute into a library, and Belle herself into a scholar of Latin and Greek.

My second favourite retelling is probably the animated Disney version, which, as Lindsey Ellis percipiently notes, shifts the dynamic character arc from Beauty to the Beast; thus, the evil sisters are scrapped with the addition of the Beast's rival, the dreadful Gaston, who is beautiful on the outside and hideous within; noble Greatheart becomes sensible Philippe, Belle's scholarship is diluted to a love of fairytales, and the previously successful merchant father is a failed inventor instead. But the developing affection between the Beast and Belle is beautifully portrayed, the side characters are heartfelt and amusing, and—Belle still loves her father, and the Beast still will die of grief if she doesn't return in time.

With nods to the original story (& let's be frank, the 1947 Cocteau film) this is a great retelling.

(You'd think the Cocteau film would also be a favourite, but when I watched it, I got the distinct feeling that the handsome, but selfish lover Beauty rejects at the beginning of the film because she wishes to care for her father instead, seemingly exchanges roles with the Beast at the end of the film; that is, the Beast gets his handsome form (played by the same actor) but also his unpleasant personality as well. Ugh! Ruined an otherwise fabulous film, at least for me. I s'pose I should note here that it obviously had impact not only the Disney version, but also McKinley.)

But, much as I love those, I'm always happy to find others, especially if they reference the classic story beats. So, while trawling the LibraryLadies reviews I discovered this recommendation of Judiet Marillier's retelling, Heart's Blood which Serena adored, and I did not finish.

I liked the protagonist's occupation, that of a (secular) scribe. Interestingly enough, according to wikipedia, anyway though the stereotype is that illuminated manuscripts were produced mostly by monks, secular workshops eventually became common; but in any event, a wandering scribe seems a bit of a stretch, as the support for producing all the paints, access to goldsmiths for the gold leaf, not to mention a source for vellum, strikes me as something easier to do with a workshop. Situated in a fairly large town. —That said, I had an acquaintance in the SCA many years ago who did authentic egg tempera based illumination, and I thought it was pretty cool.

So I liked that bit, the Beauty character having a career.

Unfortunately, that's about all I liked. The ‘Beast’ was basically ugly because of ...polio? making his body a little asymmetric, but otherwise he's handsome? But his personality seemed unformed and I found it unappealing; hers wasn't a whole lot better. Meh. Oh, I guess the undead servants were also sort of intriguing, but once I guessed who the ultimate villain was (I cheated & looked up the ending) I decided I'd had enough, and that the book was not for me.

But somehow or other—reading Goodreads reviews of it? I found a different Beauty and the Beast retelling that seemed okay, if not up to the standard of one's reviewer's fave: Cruel Beauty by Rosamund Hodge. Turns out my local library had an e-version available, so I checked it out. This one will never be a reread for me—this entire page is basically so I don't waste my time reading these books again—but I did at least stay up to 1:30 am to finish it, so in that sense it was more successful.

Certainly it was a far closer retelling, with a lot of subversion, something the title itself, makes very clear: supposing instead of being endlessly kind, Beauty were cruel? But then, how do you make that work with the original story? Plus, to give it some oomph, let's cross it with Greek mythology! If nothing else, it's a nice callback to those elements in the Cocteau film. All in all, I thought that was pretty inventive.

So we have Nyx (oddly enough, not related to the classical Greek Nyx, at least according to someone or other who didn't like the book; I myself was annoyed at a Damocles who makes a terrible bargain that involves no swords—I mean, c'mon, if you're gonna reference ancient Greek myths, at least fulfill expectations—either that, or choose a different name) and her fraternal twin sister Astraia. Our Beast would be Ignifex, lord of a crumbling castle with whom all in trapped Arcadia make desperate vows, always to their cost. Nyx's father, desiring children, bargains away the fate of one of a pair of fraternal twins to keep the other with him, choosing to keep the one like his wife, and rejecting the other to a deadly fate. Ignifex never lies, but the cost of this bargain, besides giving up one daughter as a sacrifice, is that the beloved wife, in bearing the children, dies in childbirth.

Thus, Nyx's father rears her from childhood to learn the magic that will destroy both Ignifex and his castle, thus releasing Arcadia from bondage (not to mention its weird isolation from the rest of the world), though it inevitably will mean Nyx's death as well when she's crushed by the collapsing castle. Not to mention having no backup plan if this sorcery to cause the castle to self-destruct fails, or can't be implemented. He knows this, but instead of sympathizing, he and his dead wife's sister (with whom he's having an affair) restrict Nyx’ reading to improving tales of heroes who give up their lives for duty.

Needless to say, Nyx doesn't appreciate the implication. Just a little bit!

Nyx wants to love her sister and is desperate for approval from her disgusting father, but obviously can't help deeply resenting them both. As much as she tries to be kind, she lashes out viciously to her gentle sister just before she goes away to the Beast's castle, knowing herself, therefore, to be a cruel person, deserving of her dreadful fate. Besides the greek mythology, which I thought lent a richness to the setting, I felt this subversion was pretty interesting. Because the Beast's demonic servants drive people mad, despite the offerings Ignifex demands and the Arcadians grudgingly bestow, Nyx has no qualms about destroying him, so to match Ignifex can be, and unsurprisingly is, a much sharper and meaner Beast than most.

The night-time dream Prince shows up in the shape of Shadow, who has ‘human blue’ eyes instead of red cat-slitted ones. (I thought most Greek people had brown eyes, but what do I know? I mean, why does this come up, excepting perhaps as an homage to the Disney version? But although Nyx notices the eye colour she doesn't really speculate why Shadow's eyes are blue, despite the fact that she's attempting to unravel the mystery that is Ignifex’ curse, of which Shadow is surely a part.—I think, on a meta level, it's to contrast with Ignifex’ red ones, but it's not really explored.) The story is rather unusual in that Shadow can speak, and even more so that Ignifex is aware of his ‘rival’, but it worked reasonably well for much of the book; I also liked Nyx's slow discovery of the four sigils (that she's been trained to trace to destroy the castle), and her discovery of a secret garden and its patron, a little sparrow god, a lyrical and beautifully written set-piece which may or may not have been an homage, but reminded me forcefully of McKinley's gorgeous prose, adding another layer of appreciation.

The mystery of the shrouded Arcadia, which is cut off from the sky, sun, and the rest of world, is pretty cool, and on that genre-conversation level there's sort of a similar deal going on in McKinley's other retelling, Rose Daughter, with a beautiful little gazebo; again, not at all certain it's a callback, but I appreciated this aspect of the story, which is imaginatively tied in with the curse on Ignifex’ castle.

Both in reading and in my own little fictions, I've come to believe that sticking the landing is probably the most difficult bit of plotting any book: in the beginning, with all these options, the reader can take any number of paths, satisfying to their own particular preferences; but as you get towards the end, those choices become constrained. My irritation with Nyx's changeable moods and Ignifex's sudden cruelties made for annoyance but weren't dealbreakers; but one of the important components in any B&B is Beauty returning to the castle in the nick of time to save the Beast from dying of grief over her, and here I thought the story became unnecessarily muddled.

Bonus points for either a) being dismayed by the beloved Beast disappearing with some stranger showing up (that second retelling, above, which McKinley beautifully explicates) or at the very least figuring out immediately that the portrait/dream/locket Prince is the enchanted Beast when released (Disney). One of the alterations I appreciated was that instead of Ignifex asking Nyx to marry him (he never does, IIRC), in this version he instead gives Nyx the option of guessing the his true name (and dying if she guessed wrong) to release the curse; or refusing to guess. With a setup like that, you pretty much have to have her guessing the true name (correctly) at the last minute, just as in the traditional version, Beauty answers the Beast's plea to marry him in the affirmative.

This does not happen, and worse, we have (spoilers, sigh...) instead an unwrapping of time, enchantments, and curses, via the Fates. All B&B stories have an enchantress or the like somewhere but in most versions she/he/it is pretty minimal—not so here. Owing to a barebones knowledge of Greek mythology The Sandman I had a reasonable idea of the “Kindly Ones” who are the ultimate arbiters of Ignifax’ dire bargains, and also responsible for putting the protags through the final wringer. I expect that if I carefully re-read this portion it would make more sense, but I was tired and wanted to get to bed, & checking up on Goodreads made it clear that a lot of people found this section confusing.

Personally, I think a good editor could've helped the author clean up and strengthen this part of the narrative, making for a stronger story; but in any event, kudos for the interesting setup, ancient Greek bits and unusual subversion, with some lyrical writing and intriguing setting. On the minus side, a better ending and a little cleaner character development would in my opinion add to the story.

But Page's wonderful necklace is unabashedly gorgeous.

18nov2026

cropIt took a looooooooong time, but in 2020 I finally cleaned up my notes and finished my review of one of my favourite self-published romances, Elaine Corvidae's 2011 The Sorceress's Orc, (the other being The Weaver Takes a Wife by Sheri Cobb South.) Both of these books feature what in the trade (or at least Goodreads) is called ‘slow burn’ romances, but for me the original template would be Georgette Heyer and her developing attraction by way of witty dialog (& who definitely inspired Weaver, excepting that the more enlightened South was unabashedly able to make the bastard commoner her hero, whereas the closest Heyer ever managed was plain coarse nouveau riche Jenny Chawleigh, whom her refined old-money spouse comes to appreciate but never really passionately love—and while I think A Civil Contract was one of Heyer's best novels, it's definitely not the happiest.)

But back to the point of all this, Grace Draven's Radiance. If Weaver was a rebuke to the classism in Civil Contract, and Sorceress's Orc’s greying, middle-aged protagonist to all those beautiful blonde princesses marrying handsome princes, I rather suspect the 2015 Radiance was Draven's riff on the 2011 Raven, and not just because I too thought it would be fun to play with the tropes:

  • sensible communication between initially distrusting protags
  • that becomes admiration unto love
  • montrous male protags who are
  • dark-skinned
  • black-haired
  • younger brothers
  • bodyguards (who get tortured)
  • sensible, highly educated female protags
  • who haven't experienced much in the way of affection or love
  • who have some social agency but not a great deal
  • and definitely not favoured princesses

Corvidae was pretty obviously attempting to be anti-racist in Orc, though judging from comments I've encountered over the years from assorted PoC, I'm guessing her efforts only work for white people; in any event, while I do think Draven may have borrowed the basic idea (because of the torture story beat as well as the initial setup) she made a real effort to sidestep all the racial coding, falling back to a much older story idea, that of George MacDonald's 1882 The Day Girl and the Night Boy (aka The Romance of Photogen and Nycteris), in which one character cannot bear the night and the other, the day.

Thus, Ildiko is your typical diurnal human, but the grey-skinned kai Breshan, with his pale, eerie eyes (that show neither iris nor pupil, and that I suspect are based on those of deep sea fishes, along with his pointed teeth, also a feature of many of these animals) is nocturnal, finding daylight blinding. This is one of the most interesting—and developed—aspects of their relationship, but while Ildiko is accommodating, adapting one's physiology would be extremely difficult for the average person; her transition to being a night owl wasn't terribly convincing. Much better if the author had set her up for success by being one of those folks is naturally (at least somewhat) nocturnal—they do exist, after all, and it would've been a nice touch of her becoming more comfortable with her new people, besides a night-time preference serving to be one more reason to be unsatisfied with her stultifying court life at the start of the book.

I had my issues with the culture as depicted in Orc, but it did have an assortment of subcultures that lent real interest to the story. Aside from a trade war between two human polities and a taste for fugu like venomous insect dishes by the Kai, that's mostly absent here. Just as an example, Breshan & Ildiko retreat from the Mother-in-Law-from-Hell to his border fortress, and spend a month being “too busy” doing...I have no idea. None. Zero. I mean, I guess Breshan probably had weapons practise, and possibly discussions with his steward about crops and whatnot, and his arms master/sergeant or whatever the medieval term for second-in-command is about the castle and border defense (& mebbe even some sorties) but that's just guessing from other novels with similar settings. Paladin of Souls, anyone?

Truly, what did Ildiko do all day? Embroider in her solar? She never shows the slightest interest in craft—of any kind. Not that she'd probably have the visual acuity, and if she had enough light to see, then her Kai attendants would've found it painfully bright—see, this is what I mean when I feel the cultural differences of shifting from a day to night based experience weren't really explored.

We don't see her managing the household, or playing an instrument. (The other big medieval time-waster for rich people would be praying with her psalter, but given this book is written for modern audiences, religion plays only a small role, though I did find the mortam ritual interesting.) She picks up the Kai language unrealistically quickly, but there's never any hint of a tutor or other time spent learning the language, though that would've been a realistic way to ground her in her new home. I mean, I guess I could've done a dive into wikipedia to find out what all those women running estates actually did while their men were off to slaughter Muslims during the Crusades, but the author supplying a little background would've not only have served to give us an idea of a highborn woman's daily activities, but also to ground Ildiko and Breshan in their new, and newly married, life.

One element Draven does make some effort to explain is Breshan's kind and consent-based character, which seems utterly unlikely given that he's (a) neglected and (b) a prince. Ildiko, upon meeting the Kai court (or even before) suspects nannies or other kind adults, not so carefully watched because he was the younger son, being responsible for Breshan's moral compass, a suspicion I shared; but of course, aside from Ildiko's offhand musings we never meet nor even hear of any of these people, one more irritating hole in the character building.

This is part of the book where the tone is very confusing: when Ildiko first meets her mother-in-law, Breshan encourages his new bride to stand up to his mother, and complements her for doing just that—okay, great, we have the new love standing up to the toxic parent, goody. Three stars.

But then.

It turns out the reason Breshan is so kind and gentle is that he rescued his newborn sister's ‘mortam light’ (a kind of cross between Harry Potter's pensieve and a soul) after his mother committed infanticide so as to use her infant in a power ritual. Uhhhhh, no. What gave him the courage? He's a child, and it would've meant his death, likely by horrific torture (as if having one's soul harvested isn't bad enough) if his mother ever found out. Let alone encouraging his lamb-in-the-woods bride to speak out during that early dinner party? It's as if the author changed her mind about the queen's character and motivations mid-stream, without going back to re-write the earlier behaviour.

I mean, by the time we learn about the infanticide, Breshan reveals that he's vowed to murder his mother for necromantic sorcery! I mean, sure, he could be concealing how horrific his parent is, but we never really get any sense of Ildiko coming to this realization as he peels back the layers.

In a similar way, Ildiko is supremely flexible. She's raised from birth with the idea that her marriage will be one of alliance, and though she's not looking forward to it, she doesn't actively resist the idea, so kudos for the likely more realistic depiction, as opposed to the modern ‘oh, ugh, I won't’; but quite often these women were also reared to be politically ambitious, and Ildiko...isn't. In fact, Ildiko isn't much of anything—Breshan at least is responsible for maintaining the border with his fortress home, but this woman has no skills (outside of eating repulsive food at important dinner parties) no hobbies, no ambitions, no preferences (except potatoes—and why would such a bland food repulse the Kai, anyhow? It's a relatively tasteless starch, and almost all foodways have something similar—it's the difference in taste, or sometimes texture, that ooks people out. Kai finding blue cheese disgusting—absolutely on point. But potatoes?)

Anyway.

Ildiko's extremely accommodating behaviour just wasn't believable, without something besides pragmatism to back it up. Especially coupled with the lack of development for the sort of changes she had to make. The author did a bit, attempting to capture her sense of loneliness and isolation with a garden that's beautiful at night, but withered looking in the daytime, but it just didn't seem to touch her very hard. I mean, I did a bike tour in Viet Nam, where I got to eat western food for breakfast, speak my own language with my companions, and do activities that I get to do at home, like photography and bike riding. During the day. Plus, I knew it was only for three weeks and then I'd get to go home again.

And I still suffered intense, ongoing homesickness. Ildiko doesn't. Why not?

Spoiler.

Also, consider this a content note for some pretty gruesome (to me, anyway) torture....

Besides the shift from ‘toxic mother-in-law’ (very believable) to necromantic evillllllll witch (also believable for this sort of story, but pick one, please!) then we had that torture scene, with the horrific disfigurement, which—frankly—was a fridging. That is, it serves solely to ‘harden’ Ildiko's character, because realistically, if they were gonna blind him, they would've taken both eyes, but he's left with one, so's he can still function, but missing the other, as a bigger hurdle for Ildiko to find him handsome.

While I certainly appreciate content notes, I don't often need them, but this was so out of left field that I wanted one for this. Ugh.

/end spoiler

We were not set up for this. The story does not have the gritty historical setting for this; instead, much of the book focuses on the developing relationship of the characters, and frankly Breshan's eyes were already creepy (in fact both Breshan and Ildiko find the other's eyes creepy—Ildiko crossing her eyes to freak Breshan and other Kai out is one of those humourous bits that make the story funny). Like the toxic-to-evil parent bait-and-switch, I kinda feel the author wanted to up the stakes, instead of making the effort to do solid world building that would've provided more realistic challenges (e.g. Ildiko adapting to living at night, or, say, how either of them feel about not having children—they never even discuss it, even to say, never wanted kids anyway, what a relief, let alone that other medieval stopgap for barren parents, what about adoption, and how does Ildiko feel about being unable to carry out the most important duty of bearing an heir? I mean, yes, Breshan has a ton of nephews, so he doesn't need an heir; but how about relief that no heirs means no danger of necromantic antics being played upon their children?—and given Breshan's care of his sister, I would've expected him, at least, to mourn that option, just a bit.)

Sigh. So many opportunities to make this a richer story, wasted.

Then we have Ildiko's order to kill Breshan's remaining captors, after extracting relevant information from them. Ildiko hesitates, but then allows her rage and desire for revenge to take over aaaaaaaannnnd...nothing. There are no consequences, not even self-reflection of what this war, with other humans, is doing to her.(1)

But, kudos on the consent based relationship, which was great, and the fact that I read the book cover to cover, without skipping to the end, which I find myself doing all too often nowadays. There's two more in the series, and I guess I have to decide whether I care enough to read the next one—seems kind of unlikely, unless there's a new couple introduced (which is hinted at.)


(1)One of things I really appreciate about the Bujoldian view is its encompassing mercy; alas, I am an unkind person, and this hesitation caused me to flashback to a) Miles’ guilt over ordering torture and b) thinking a case could be made that, at this point, we switched from “sorcerous” Dag's extremely toxic mother-in-law in WGW to evil, soul-harvesting enchantress Joen in Paladin and why yes at this point I'm guessing the author was indeed inspired by Bujold. Ha!

17nov2026

cropSo I reread 10 LB Penalty by Dick (& Mary) Frances, mostly because all the rest of them are packed up in the attic. I love Dick Frances thrillers and have been enjoying them my entire adult life(1): appealing protagonists, women who are people, exposure to cool jobs/crafts/industries(2) and reasonably twisty mysteries.

It's a later one, (antepenultimate for the other $64 word lovers out there) and kind of unusual in that most of the story takes place when the character is a child, as opposed to the typical 30 something protag, often doing okay but just a bit adrift. This kid knows exactly what he wants to do: become a jockey. Unfortunately he has neither the figure nor talent for his dream job, so his politically ambitious father shifts his ‘gap year’ out from under him, asking Ben, the 17 year old protagonist, to become family window dressing, since Ben's mom died shortly after giving birth, and his father, George Julliard, never remarried.

Ben reluctantly agrees, though he feels politicking is the height of boredom after the adrenaline of racing; and while all Frances protagonists are very bright, Ben has a preternatural insight into human nature. (To the point that many readers found it unbelievable: I liked that bit, I guess cuz as a probably-sorta-autistic type I have a terrible time sussing that stuff out. I also suspect it's Dick Frances’ own superpower, because his self-insert narrator's insights into people is superb, and I think...in a way...this also is his reminiscing on his own youth.)

Ben's also fearless, becoming invested in his parent's desire to win a by-election particularly after nearly being shot. In this, he contrasts with some of my favourite protagonists—perhaps the most famous being Sid Halley, who has a prosthetic hand, and is reduced to a quivering wreck when threatened with losing his other; or the rather timid heroes of Reflex and Proof, who are unmoored by a lack of family and the belief he'll never measure up to his father's bravery, respectively (or the guy with the transport business who has a —literally—crushing phobia he must overcome to save his daughter) who must overcome their fears to achieve manhood self-acceptance. (Honestly, the word that comes to mind is ‘self-actualization’, and as clunky, new-agey and Silicon Valley as it is, I wasn't really able to come up with a better.)

Ben's response, however, to any kind of threat is aggression—without fear. I didn't mind Ben's wanting to fight. I just couldn't believe that someone so precociously imaginative could fail to see some truly dire consequences, nor why the author(s) made this choice about his personality. But, again, this is something that seems only to bother me, not others.

So in contrast to these guys who basically spend the typical Dick Frances thriller finding their centers, Ben already knows what he wants; when that's taken away from him, he manages to substitute the high of racing for the danger of battling his father's foes. (Also we get some insights to how elections and voting work in the UK. One snarky commenter on Goodreads notes that the book was written before the scandals of the 2000s, criticizing its ‘elections can't be bought becuz severe campaign spending limits’ naivete, but nevertheless I found it pretty interesting, as it's quite different from US elections, which drag on way longer and involve huge sums of advertising.)

Those same goodreads commenters—well one in particular, a self-identified writer—noted the weird structure of the book, a novel plus novella, as the guy put it: we have the first 2/3rds or so of the book, centered on a three week (or so) campaign, and then some major time-skips, during which Ben finishes school, figures out a (very) satisfying career, has three fabulous years racing a horse whom he loves...and loses. And he and his father recross paths with the villain, now able to move the levers of government, who resents the elder Julliard's meteoric rise.

And (really truly yes, spoiler now) reprises his first efforts to shoot his rival dead. This time, Ben fails entirely to elude the bullet meant for the father he swore to protect, aaaaaaand he loses, forever, the ability to race. In effect, Ben ends this book in the position most Frances heroes start: having lost (or never really gained) a real sense of purpose. Broken hearted, he grips the hand of the new prime minister, having given up the dream most dear to him—racing (however imperfectly, amatuerishly, or mediocrely) at the exact moment his father acheives his superlative one. Boom, end, sharp as the loss itself.

/endeth spoilers.

It's a gut punch, frankly, and the reason why I happen to think the book works, despite its flaws.

In fact, I'd argue it was the last really good Dick Frances novel—I didn't like the meteorologist one because the protag seemed unlikable (as I recall) and the macguffin in the last Dick Frances, Shattered, just annoyed me as a glassworker (I'm not saying it couldn't work, only that it seems really far-fetched, because the situation, of letting hot, unannealed glass rapidly cool is one any glassblower, even lampworker like myself, very much tries to avoid precisely because how it's gonna, ahem, shatter, is so unpredictable. Plus there were some other issues with technique and so on that seemed kind of improbable.)(3)

However, no-one besides me, in at least the reviews I was able to find, really seems to have thought the ending of this book was so affecting; so then I went trawling for Felix-Frances-hate, because one of the things that I really appreciate about Frances is his insight into people—even characters with quite small parts, or who seem average, let alone averagely annoying (the endlessly talking resale shop lady, a veritable Miss Bates, frex) is still treated with sympathy and kindness. —That all disappeared with Felix, and that's why I don't like his books, in contrast to his father's. It surprised me, that he failed to grasp this essential element of his father's parents’ success, except most reviews seem to approve.

But at any rate, I discovered the library ladies. And tons of recces. More about all that anon, but in the meantime, a very quick watercolour sketch.


(1)Child-aged prudish me was a bit taken aback at the hero's lusting over someone else's wife the first time I read Frances, which IIRC was my intro to adult mysteries (outside of Sherlock Holmes, of course), but upon re-reading some years later, adult me was a little surprised to discover he behaves appropriately. Obviously, I had a very faerytale morality as a young something. Not even the palest shade of grey, please and thank you. I did eventually get over that to some extent, but still don't appreciate morally grey storylines the way others can.

(2)My absolute fave was a textile artist who designed and wove custom designed...jacquard? fabric incorporating gold threads. Her studio (& home) is a decommissioned church, a gorgeous setting that the narrator says the artist ‘must be very secure to live and work in such a space’. Because she's working for the 1%, she's also independent, and this depiction of a happy, secure and fulfilled maker was so appealing that I really hoped she was based on a real person. Also passementerie! (A fancy french word for braids and tassels and other sorts of trimmings that I love. That said, the villain's kink is one of most horrifying I ever encountered in the author's oeuvre, coming perilously close to triggering OCD type thoughts in me.)

(3)Other very quite small & technical nits I have as an artist with these books—the one that starts out with the fabulous opening of

I inherited my brother's life, and it nearly killed me...

features a gem and bead wholesaler, and I worked for a gemstone bead wholesaler (we didn't carry cut stones, those are a very different market in the US) and I'm sorry but you don't call up your importer because you've run out of 6mm (or was it 8?) bluelace agate beads, especially not if your main product line is the far more expensive cut stones—black onyx, mebbe, but not something so out-of-the-way. You'd wait till you needed a bunch of stuff, then place a bigger order. I mean, mebbe if it were for your absolute best customer, but definitely not because you ran out of that one thing. You'd just say it was out of stock, ask again in three months. That's because the importers expect you to buy thousands of dollars and hundreds of strands at a time. In emergencies we would order from a NYC dealer, but even then they had pretty high minimum orders, and because they were way more expensive, typically this stuff comes direct from factories in Hong Kong, Taiwan, or China (or India, but the Frances shop evidently didn't buy from India IIRC) shipped on a boat; again, emergency orders might be flown in, but that'd be for the popular stuff, like black onyx or freshwater pearls.

The other was Reflex —I liked all the photographic puzzles, but they seemed too disparate. People, when they're figuring out things (i.e. being creative) tend to build on prior ideas, refining them. There just wasn't a through-line that I could see, though granted I've had exactly one class on photography, and am not especially good at it.

And to be fair, I loved the painting ones, (one in oils, the other in acrylics) especially the ‘bloody chromic oxide’ epithet the hero tells his friend as code that he's being held hostage by the villainous ‘Greene. With an E.’ Even though I gave up on oils after one or two tries, because even odourless turps made me sick to my stomach, I especially liked that it had two, and two distinct working styles—that of the narrator, and of his best friend. Plus quite believable observations on the (at least moderately) affordable gallery scene:)

Ok, rant over. I know it's petty, but I've wanted to get the two points above out of my system for the better part of twenty or 30 years.

16nov2026

cropHappy Monday all. It's hard to believe we're halfway through the penultimate month of 2026 already...

My most memorable college job was acting an assistant to a man with severe cerebral palsy, who was in the process of getting his masters in social work. I suspect Paul would have been intimately familiar with Hale Zukas (who wore the same sort of stick and helmet device to spell out letters that Paul did back in the 80s, when I was his employee—I'm guessing these guys had roughly contemporaneous birthdates, though sadly Paul died years ago). Zukas, a disability activist, advocated for independent living, and in service to this, created curb cuts as a right for wheelchair users. They're so ubiquitous now it's hard to remember that they became the default in my lifetime; and yanno who else really appreciates ’em? Bicyclists.

I s'pose I oughta save this link about a gorgeous goblet recreated in the roman style for a glass bead page, preferably one featuring silver bearing glass, but eh, it's already been sitting around forever (at least a week, mebbe two). The headline is slightly annoying, because while it's a marvelous achievement, and a technical tour-de-force, but, um, silver bearing glass (& its temperature & reduction colour shifts) has been around forever, not just “rediscovered”, but you'd have to be pretty embedded in the glassworking world to know that. And it really is a beautiful piece of dichroic glass.

Via Fred Clark/Slacktivist, The Dam Broke —the author (whose name I frustratingly can't find...!) suggests that progressives should adopt the metaphor of the water finally breaking the dam (rather than a dam holding back a flood of corruption); it was part of that ‘if only voters under 30 had voted, the entire country would be painted blue’ meme. It's certainly a more appealing image the holding a bulwark against a tide of filth (ugh) but to be honest I just like the Japanese ukiyo-e print of a waterfall used to illustrate the essay; f2tY's Japanese “father” took us to see a very similar (possibly the same—I think it's the tallest in Japan?) and told me it was his very favourite part of Japan. So that print has a lot of resonance for me:)

Another link saved as much for the illustration of its subject (that I'd like to try drawing), the beautiful kangaroo-resembling ‘swamp wallaby’ (now there's a crittur saddled with an unattractive name) as its fascinating biology: these animals are among the few that can get pregnant while already pregnant..

More familiar to me are New York City's Bodega Cats whom I've encountered while visiting my glass daughter in Brooklyn; it doesn't surprise me to learn they're technically illegal, but that they serve a very real purpose in keeping the rodent population down: NYC is infamously home to a huge population of rats, which exploded when the city shifted from hard-sided garbage cans to plastic bags. I gather the city is in the process of reversing this decision, but I think legalizing the cats makes a lot of sense—it is, after all, probably how they became domesticated in the first place:)

I know everyone detests youtube's algorithm, but it happened to throw up this splendid PBS documentary of Ursula K. LeGuin. It was so nice to see some of other great women authors of her era, such Vonda McIntyre (she and Joan Vinge, along with LeGuin herself, are three from that era who have, for me, stood the test of time.) I'm not certain exactly when it was shot, though obviously before 2018, when she died, & definitely before Neil Gaiman's rep crashed and burnt, as he's a commenter. Although I never felt “betrayed” by Tehanu (the 4th book in the Earthsea trilogy) and the like, I liked her earlier stuff better; like Peter Grant's inability to follow his dad's jazz genius, her later, more challenging work was ...too difficult for this genre reader to pursue.

But.

True names were a huge theme of A Wizard of Earthsea, her first and arguably most famous YA novel, one of many I read in the library while waiting for dad to get off work & pick me up) and for that I will be forever grateful: because it directly inspired me to adopt my adult name, eventually shedding the girly, religiously themed birth name. —There are other books I've loved more, re-read more often, but I'd argue this one has probably had the greatest—certainly the most measurable—impact on my life.

Aaaaaaaand here's a lil’ sunset sketch.

7nov2026

cropMy efforts to tidy up links finish up reviews so's I can return library books continues.

Rivers Solomon, Sorrowland —one of those books the blurb writers like to call ‘searing’ —Solomon certainly has the right to rage in their SFnal take on how an alphabet org colludes? collides? —ultimately perverts a patriarchal, fundamentalist cult compound and the separatist Black families living there to achieve their goals. This book, which the library was featuring in an October display of horror themed books, had several blurbs by authors I at least recognized, most notably Charlie Jane Anders (whose work I s'pose I oughta try some day) and a pretty, eerie cover with strong vibes of botanical illustration. The first page (of wild birth no less) was lyrically written. Why not? So I checked it out, and yes, it's well written. It's also definitely SF (I really do think my problem with a lot of the books I've read recently is this current fashion of crossing over one's genres, and I haven't quite got used to that, yet) and has mild elements of body horror.

Not to mention culturally distinct approaches to child-rearing that I found fascinating. Now that I've had time to think about it, I believe the thing I appreciate most about this book, besides its very authentically depicted protagonist, is the way the story indicts both the appallingly racist treatment by the gov't org but also the appallingly sexist treatment by the cult leader.

Kindt, Matt (writer), Jean-Denis Pendanx (artist) and Jim Campbell (letterer), Mister Mammoth. Another ‘evil schemers experiment on innocent children’ story. Come to think, it's been a rather common theme in the fiction, especially mysteries, that I've been reading (it's part of that Birds one I reviewed a while back). That part of the story works just fine, but the conceit of this graphic novel is that the titular character is the ultimate gentle giant, who never hurts anyone, just takes whatever punishment people choose to dish out, his super-body healing from (nearly?) all wounds, I guess. That part needs to be a bit clearer for the book to work. I mean, I'm fine with the idea that he can solve any case, it's an axiom of the setup, but the writer did not make a convincing case that he never, ever hurt anyone, that it was a fundamental part of his humanity. I mean, why would someone be like that, especially if they were horrifically tortured to make them what they are?

Without that critical component, the basic plot of what is, in effect, a revenge story, makes for rather (ahem) colourless reading, despite the richness of Pendanx's painterly art. Also—nitpick—if you're going to have a secondary character wearing a vivid floral blouse, at least change the pattern from scene to scene, it's beyond belief that some one who cares enough about her appearance to tie up her shirt in a mid-riff baring way would not swap out her top from day to day, to wash if nothing else. Give her a closet of similar but distinct shirts, then the reader can have fun tracking them through the story.

I made this page as a reference so I could make a painting of it;)

6nov2026

cropReally, I ought to track down Nozomi Naoi's The Land of Happiness, given my interest in Japan, but even the excerpts (especially the poster art) of its century old department stores is pretty fascinating, partially, I suppose, cuz the F2’s made a point of dragging me all over several in Kyoto in search of leather goods this summer: I, of course, haven't really felt comfortable with the USian versions since I was a child and the neighborhood's “big” multi-story cream-coloured art deco Hudson's near my house was closed down, slowly becoming a ruin until it was at last torn down—and why yes my mother-in-law used to tell me charming stories of taking the trolley, decked out in white gloves and having lunch on the sixth floor with her mother and sister of the huge flagship store downtown, a bygone era 30–40 years go and basically unimaginable now—but department stores very much are still a thing in Japan.

To be honest shopping is very much a thing in Japan, and after all those stupid tariffs were instituted, plus the exchange rate, I gave myself permission to buy stuff stuff while I was over there. In other words, I bought two new outfits and at least three pairs of cotton socks. (Oh and a serger, since it cost about a thousand dollars less than the US version.)

But mostly I trailed after the indefatigable f2tE who had a grand old time, especially at the myriad flea markets—Kyoto has oodles of temples and old stuff, and since flea markets are quite often staged on temple courtyards (there's not really space to have them on the streets or parks like we do here in the US) there's plenty of those too. Plus little vintage shops.

Then of course, was the fun of transporting all this stuff home, which thankfully was not my problem. Postcards or paintings to give away were much easier to dispose of.